A Bad Sign

I don't mean to continue piling on, but you know it's bad when your team's General Manager feels the need to make an official statement on the team's official website to sell you on a trade he's made.  That's like your boss sending out a company wide newsletter to try and sell you on the idea that getting rid of lunch breaks, coffee machines, and toilet paper is good for the company.

What I found particularly funny was this:

"Charlie Morton is a power right-handed starting pitcher with upside, who should be ready to help us this year in Pittsburgh. In fact, in his first outing for our Triple-A affiliate, he tossed seven scoreless innings, giving up only four hits while striking out seven. Jeff Locke is an intriguing young left handed starter with the frame, athleticism and stuff to become a quality major league starting pitcher. Gorkys Hernandez is a dynamic athlete who has the speed and potential to become an above average everyday major league outfielder. It is worth noting that these three players were rumored to be sought by the Padres when they were talking to the Braves about trading former Cy Young award winner Jake Peavy."

The phrases that immediately stand out to me are upside, intriguing, quality, and above average.  They stand out to me because they don't fit in; all of them are qualifiers, and pretty much every time you hear them come from the mouth of a sports General Manager they're trying to sell you on something that isn't worth buying.  When you trade an All-Star, a 5-tool player who, aside from being your best player, is the backbone of your team, you shouldn't have to use such tangible hypotheticals to try and sell your fans on once again trading away their star.  But he (Huntington) saves the best (err, worst) part of the paragraph for last when he tries to convince you that the three players he just got, they were good enough to land a Cy Young winner in Jake Peavy, but the Braves couldn't bring themselves to give them away in that trade; that they were waiting on this one like this to come around instead.  Yeah.  Sure.  Do you think it's closer to the truth that the Padres laughed at the offer/deal question, at any offer the Braves sent them without the inclusion of Tommy Hanson in it, and that's why Jake Peavy is still a Padres pitcher and not on the Braves?  Huntington reminds me of that guy from the movie Office Space who came up with the "Jump To Conclusions" mat, and despite being told "That's the worst idea I've ever heard" is still convinced its the greatest thing ever; his million dollar moneymaking idea.  Three horrible trades within the past year later, Huntington is still trying to sell the idea that taking the ugly girl to the prom is the way to go.  "It's not what she looks like; it's what she could look like with a little work."  Yeah.  Sure.  That old saying, "If it looks like (insert word here), and smells like (insert word here), then chances are it's (insert word here)", that about sums Huntington's actions the way I see it.  That dude from Office Space, he got "lucky"; while backing out of his driveway, seconds after trying to kill himself, he gets railed by a speeding driver and receives a fat insurance settlement because of it.  He was able to make his "Jump To Conclusions" prototype, and of course, it was just as stupid as it sounded to everyone but him; no, to him it's the greatest thing ever.  It's too bad that Pirates fans have grown so accustomed to buying that every time their team sells off anything worth keeping, they're left with yet another "Jump To Conclusions" mat as their reward.  

3 Comments

I'm not liking all the pessimism here... Andrew McCutchen is a better centerfielder than Nate McLouth, and he will soon be better at the plate as well.

http://eatsleepmlb.mlblogs.com

I'm not a Pirates fan, but from afar, I can't see how, as a Pirates fan, you could be anything but a pessimist. They haven't been a contending team since Barry Bonds left almost 20 years ago. Anybody worth rooting for gets traded. Sure, as a smaller market team, that's part of the deal; I understand that. But when your team trades top-tier talent at the height of their trade value, and gets nothing worthwhile or sustainable in return, all that's doing is perpetuating the cycle of losing, excuse making, and "Just bear with us" type statements.

Sure, Andrew McCutchen is a fun player; someone who will be a very good player who is easy to root for. And I don't doubt that, in other ways, by the end of this year, he'll be almost as productive as Nate McLouth is now, and in the long run will surpass McLouth's production. But that's not the point. The point is that if you're going to trade premium value, you should get premium value in return; people to compliment the few McCutchen's you actually have in your system. McCutchen is there now. Alvarez, who came in with a MLB contract, will have to be there sooner than later. If you want to win you can't trade MLB All-Stars for A level talent with "promise" who may or may not pan out, or even worse, AAA talent who is merely better than what you had (see Karstens, Moss, LaRoche, Olhendorf, etc.) Jason Bay is a premier LFer. The Pirates got crap for him. From two organizations who are completely stacked with young high-end talent. Nady and Marte were both good players having great seasons. The Yankees handed over three marginal pitchers who are best served in AAA, and a prospect who went from untouchable in a Johan Santana trade to agreeable in what easily could have been for two rental players. When they have high-end young pitchers like Phil Hughes, Ian Kennedy, Joba Chamberlain, and Andrew Brackman and young hitters like Austin Jackson, Melky Cabrera, or Jesus Montero. And it happened again a couple days ago with the McLouth trade. Seeing that, as I said, if I were a Pirates fan, how could I be anything more than a pessimist.

Believe me, I know. I'm a Yankees fan. (And before anyone spews the usual $200 million garbage they inevitably do...) I'm 30-years old. Until I was 17, the Yankees winning aura was merely history; all they did was lose, they were horrible--I will go so far as saying "the worst"--at personnel decisions. There are so many famous ones that got away: Fred McGriff, Willie McGee, Jay Buhner, Al Leiter, and so on and so on. And then they turned it around. They learned their lesson; keep the core players, when you trade, trade for value. See Paul O'Neill. See Scott Brosius. See Tino Martinez. See Jeff Nelson. And so on...

When you're as bad as the Pirates have been for as long as they've been, it's not just coincidence. And personally, I don't see their latest three moves as being anything other than a continuance of failure; the same as making a sequel to Dude, Where's My Car, only over and over again.

I do like McCutchen. But McLouth was a pretty good player too.
-Dillon
http://dillonm.mlblogs.com

Leave a comment